payclear.

Salary comparison calculator

Compare up to three salaries or job offers side by side, including employee against contractor pay, Scottish rates and different pensions.

Which plan am I on? Check on GOV.UK (opens in a new tab)

Try:
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C

Side-by-side comparison

Enter a salary in at least two scenarios to compare them.

Or start from a quick comparison above.

  • Take-home pay, tax and NI for each scenario
  • Differences against scenario A
  • Pension, effective rates and pay per day worked

Estimates using the selected tax year’s HMRC rates. How this works

How the salary comparison works

Each scenario is calculated separately with the same engine as the PayClear salary calculator, then set side by side. Differences are shown against scenario A, so put your current job or salary first.

You can change the type of work, pension, employer pension and tax jurisdiction for each scenario. Tax year and student loan apply to all of them, because they belong to you rather than to the job.

Worked example: £40,000, £50,000 and £60,000

2026/27, England, Wales and Northern Ireland, tax code 1257L, no pension or student loan.

£40,000£50,000£60,000
Gross salary£40,000£50,000£60,000
Income Tax£5,486£7,486£11,432
National Insurance£2,194£2,994£3,211
Take-home a year£32,320£39,520£45,357
Take-home a month£2,693£3,293£3,780
Extra take-home vs £40,000–+£7,200+£13,038
Tax and NI as % of pay19.2%21%24.4%

The first £10,000 of the rise adds £7,200 of take-home pay; the next £10,000 adds only £5,838, because most of it is above the £50,270 higher-rate threshold. You keep about 58p of each pound there.

Comparing employment with contracting

A contract day rate and a salary are not like for like. As an employee you are paid for holidays and bank holidays, get sick pay and usually an employer pension, and your employer pays employer National Insurance. A contractor pays for all of these from the day rate, and only earns on the days worked.

PayClear shows the costs it can calculate: Corporation Tax, employer NI, business expenses and umbrella margins. It also shows take-home plus pension and take-home per day worked, which make a fairer comparison. Example for 2026/27:

Employee on £70,000Limited company, £400 a dayUmbrella, £400 a day
Income£70,000£88,000£88,000
Take-home a year£49,127£58,598£54,663
Into pension£7,000£0£0
Days worked232 (28 days’ paid holiday)220220
Take-home per day worked£212£266£248

The employee has 5% salary sacrifice and a 5% employer contribution. The limited company figures assume work outside IR35, a £12,570 director’s salary with the rest taken as dividends, £2,000 of expenses and no Employment Allowance. Inside IR35 the contract would be taxed much like employment.

What is not included

  • Benefits such as private medical insurance, company cars or share schemes.
  • Gaps between contracts, unpaid sick days and the cost of insurance or an accountant beyond the expenses you enter.
  • Other income, such as savings interest or rent.

Sources

Rates checked against HMRC and Scottish Government publications. Page updated 1 November 2026.

Saved scenarios

Scenarios you save here or in the salary calculator stay in this browser on this device. Pick one in any column with “Use a saved scenario”.

No saved scenarios yet.

Related calculators

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare two job offers?

Enter each salary as a scenario, with the pension each employer offers. Look at take-home pay and at take-home plus pension, since a higher employer pension can be worth more than a small salary difference.

Why is the take-home difference smaller than the salary difference?

Each extra pound is taxed at your marginal rate. Between £12,570 and £50,270 an employee keeps 72p of each extra pound (20% tax, 8% NI); between £50,270 and £100,000 they keep 58p, and between £100,000 and £125,140 only 38p.

Can I compare a contract rate with a permanent salary?

Yes, but the figures are not directly equivalent. Contractors are not paid for holidays or sickness and usually get no employer pension, and pay costs such as Corporation Tax or umbrella fees. Compare take-home per day worked and take-home plus pension, and remember the limited company figures assume you are outside IR35.

Does the comparison include Scottish tax?

Yes. Choose Scotland for any scenario. Scotland has six Income Tax rates on earnings; National Insurance is the same across the UK.

Are my scenarios stored anywhere?

Only if you save them, and then only in your own browser. Nothing is sent to PayClear. You can delete saved scenarios at any time.

Disclaimer: PayClear provides estimates using published UK tax rates and standard payroll assumptions. It is not financial, tax or legal advice. Your actual pay can differ because of your tax code, payroll practices and personal circumstances. PayClear is independent and not affiliated with HMRC or GOV.UK. Full disclaimer